Is this worth returning to Sephora?

If you are not happy with the product then I would return it and lose the $6.00 since keeping it and not using it is like losing $22.00. The actual return shipping is free through Sephora if you use the return label from the first order so at least you won't be out another shipping fee. Sorry that happened! I have had countless bad makeup experiences and there are times I just give the item away because it is too expensive to bother returning and every time that happens it stinks!